Book/Printed Material The debates in the several state conventions on the adoption of the federal Constitution, as recommended by the general convention at Philadelphia, in 1787. Together with the journal of the Federal convention, Luther Martin's letter, Yate's minutes, Congressional opinions, Virginia and Kentucky resolutions of '98-'99, and other illustrations of the Constitution volume 5
-
Image 1 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates DEBATES ON THE ADOPTION OF THE FEDERAL CONSTITUTION. IN THE CONVENTION HELD AT PHILADELPHIA, IN 1787; WITH A DIARY OF THE DEBATES OF THE CONGRESS OF THE CONFEDERATION; AS REPORTED BY JAMES…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 2 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year one thousand eight hundred and forty-five, By JONATHAN ELLIOT, In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the District of Columbia. By…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 3 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates ADVERTISEMENT. Under the sanction of Congress, this new edition of Madison's Debates of the Federal Convention, held in 1787 has been prepared, revised, and the matter remodelled agreeably to the consecutive order…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 4 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 5 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates CONTENTS. DEBATES IN THE CONGRESS OF THE CONFEDERATION, FROM NOVEMBER 4, 1782, TO JUNE 21, 1783; AND FROM FEBRUARY 19 TO APRIL 25, 1787. Monday, November 4, 1 Elias Boudinot chosen president—Letters…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 6 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates vi Friday, December 6, 12 Ordinance extending the franking privilege to the heads of departments discussed—Motion relative to statements by a member in a Boston newspaper—Motions of Mr. Hamilton and Mr. Rutledge,…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 7 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates vii Wednesday, January 15, 25 Evacuation of Charleston. Friday, January 17, 26 Misrepresentations in South Carolina of European negotiation—Report of the committee on foreign Loans—Vote of thanks to Gen. Greene—Mr. Webster and…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 8 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates viii Thursday, March 6, 62 Report of the committee on revenue ordered to be printed. Friday, March 7, 62 Printed reports delivered to the members —Resolutions contained is the report. Monday, March…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 9 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates ix the cessions of the states—Passage of the plan of revenue. Monday, April 21, 87 Motion relative to expenses incurred by individual states. Wednesday, April 23, 87 Resolution permitting soldiers to retain…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 10 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates x and Mr. Bingham with Mr. Guardoqui relative to the navigation of the Mississippi—Discontents in the western territory—Posts held by the British. Tuesday, March 20, 98 Mr. Jay's report relative to the…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 11 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xi at Annapolis, in 1786—Recommends Federal Convention—Proceedings of Virginia and other states—Previous suggestions for a convention by Pelatiah Webster, Gen. Schuyler, Alexander Hamilton, Richard H. Lee, and Noah Webster—Defects to be provided…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 12 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xii oath to support the national government—Postponed. Mr. Randolph's fifteenth proposition—The Constitution to be ratified by conventions of the people of the states recommended by the state legislatures—Postponed. Motion to strike out…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 13 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xiii the supreme tribunal be appointed by the second branch (Senate) of the national legislature—Agreed to. Motion to amend that part of the sixth proposition which empowers each branch to originate acts…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 14 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xiv Thursday, June 28, 249 Seventh resolution, fixing the right of suffrage in the first branch, resumed—Motion to amend so as to provide that the right of suffrage in the first branch…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 15 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xv Saturday, July 14, 310 Seventh resolution, relative to the proportion of suffrage in the first branch resumed—Motion that the number of representatives in the first branch, from new states, shall never…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 16 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xvi Nineteenth resolution, requiring the ratification of the Constitution by state conventions—Motion to amend by providing for its reference to the state legislatures—Disagreed to—Motion to a second Federal Convention—Not seconded. The eighth…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 17 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xvii below a majority—Disagreed to—Motion to authorize the compulsory attendance of members—Agreed to—Motion to require a vote of two thirds to expel a member—Agreed to—Motion to allow a single member to call…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 18 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xviii the clauses relative to the importation and migration of slaves, and to a capitation tax, and navigation act, to a grand committee—Agreed to—Motion to prohibit attainders or ex post facto laws—Agreed…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 19 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xix regulating foreign commerce—Disagreed to—Motion to strike out the provision requiring two thirds of each House on navigation acts—Agreed to. Article fifteenth, relative to the delivery of persons fleeing to other states,…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 20 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xx —Motion to exclude members of the legislature, and public officers, from being electors—Agreed to—Motion to extend the executive term to seven and six years—Disagreed to—Motion to elect the executive by electors—Agreed…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 21 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xxi the Constitution—Motion to require Congress to call a convention on an application of two thirds of the states—Agreed to. Article first, relative to the legislative power, resumed—Motion to guaranty to the…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 22 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates xxii To Edmund Randolph. New York, October 17, 1788, 575 Effect of American revolution on reform in Europe—Mr. Madison's sentiments on being a candidate for Congress. To Edmund Randolph. New York, November…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 23 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 1 DEBATES IN THE CONGRESS OF THE CONFEDERATION, FROM NOVEMBER 14, 1782, TO FEBRUARY 13, 1783. In Congress, Monday, November 4, 1782. Elias Boudinot was chosen president, by the votes of New…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 24 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 2 letter of General Carleton and Admiral Digby, notifying the purpose of the British king to acknowledge our independence, it was thought expedient by Congress to assume a higher tone. It was…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 25 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 3 the circumstance urged in its favor; and that the disavowal of the outrage by the British general, and a solemn promise to pursue the guilty authors of it, afforded the most…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 26 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 4 military commanders, they had proceeded on doubtful authority. To remove this objection, the amendment was proposed limiting the preamble to the single act of discharging Captain Asgill. This, however, was not…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 27 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 5 by New York to the latter; that the jurisdiction would probably be equally resisted, and the same violences would follow as in Vermont. He was called to order by Mr. MADISON.…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 28 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 6 States, all such temporary corps as had been raised by them respectively, with the approbation of Congress. The repugnance which appeared in Congress to go into so extensive and important a…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 29 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 7 the commission for peace would not be affected by any mark of disapprobation which might fall on his conduct; that no injury could accrue to Dr. Franklin, because he had guarded…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 30 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 8 The committee were unanimous that justice required an allowance to the states who should sink a surplus, to be apportioned on the different states. The different expedients were— That Congress should…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 31 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 9 arguments on this side, in general, came from Mr. HOWELL, of Rhode Island, whose object was to render the proceedings of Congress as favorable as possible to the independence of Vermont.…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 32 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 10 The report of the committee on the case of Vermont, mentioned on Thursday, the 14th of November, was called for by Mr. M'KEAN, and postponed, on his motion, to make way…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 33 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 11 subject of the memorials, and was instructed to make such communications, relative to our affairs abroad, as would correct misinformations. The committee which met them, on the part of the legislature,…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 34 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 12 Smith, of New Jersey, had the vote of that state, and Mr. Merchant, of Rhode Island, the vote of that state. The resolutions respecting Vermont, moved by Mr. M'KEAN on the…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 35 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 13 the appearance of being written by a member of Congress. The unanimous suspicions were fixed on Mr. Howell. The mischievous tendency of such publications, and the necessity of the interposition of…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 36 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 14 of our situation, and the chance of giving a favorable turn to the negotiations on foot for peace, rendered it of little comparative significance. the objections were finally retracted, and both…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 37 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 15 for settling accounts m Europe, agreed to by Congress, see Secret Journal of this date. Wednesday , December 11. The secretary of war was authorized to permit the British prisoners to…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 38 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 16 reprobated, when the author was found to be a member of Congress, prevented a relaxation as to the yeas and nays. Mr. HOWELL, therefore, as his name was necessarily to appear…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 39 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 17 and joined in the same commission, they, the ministers, wrote separately , and breathed opposite sentiments as to the views of France. Mr. Livingston told me that the letter of the…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
-
Image 40 of volume 5
Also known as Elliot's debates 18 and prognosticated a failure of the impost scheme, and the most pernicious effects to the character, the duration, and the interests, of the Confederacy. It was at length, notwithstanding, determined to…- Contributor: United States. Constitutional Convention - Elliot, Jonathan - Madison, James
- Date: 1836
- Resource: - 1 page
About this Item
Title
- The debates in the several state conventions on the adoption of the federal Constitution, as recommended by the general convention at Philadelphia, in 1787. Together with the journal of the Federal convention, Luther Martin's letter, Yate's minutes, Congressional opinions, Virginia and Kentucky resolutions of '98-'99, and other illustrations of the Constitution
Other Title
- Also known as Elliot's debates
Names
- Elliot, Jonathan, 1784-1846, ed
- Madison, James, 1751-1836
- United States. Constitutional Convention (1787)
Created / Published
- Philadelphia, J.B. Lippincott & co.; Washington, Taylor & Maury, 1836-59.
Headings
- - United States.--Constitution
Notes
- - Imprint varies: v. 1-2, 1859; v. 3-4, Washington, Printed for the editor, 1836; v. 5, 1845.
- - Vol. 5 has title: Debates on the adoption of the federal Constitution, in the convention held at Philadelphia, in 1787; with a diary of the debates of the Congress of the Confederation; as reported by James Madison ... Rev. and newly arranged by Jonathan Elliot ... Supplementary to Elliot's Debates ... 1845.
- - Wilson copy : Vol. 5 inscribed, A. W. Hazen, 1885.
- - Note on catalogue card: Library has vol. 5. Not sure if "Library" is all of LC or only Wilson Collection. LAC tnb 2021-12-22.
- - LAC tnb 2021-12-22 update (2 cards)
Medium
- 5 v. 24 cm.
Call Number/Physical Location
- KF4502 .E5 1836b
Digital Id
- http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.law/amlaw.lwed
- https://hdl.loc.gov/loc.law/llscd.lled001
- https://hdl.loc.gov/loc.law/llscd.lled002
- https://hdl.loc.gov/loc.law/llscd.lled003
- https://hdl.loc.gov/loc.law/llscd.lled004
- https://hdl.loc.gov/loc.law/llscd.lled005
Library of Congress Control Number
- 17007172
OCLC Number
- 21660359
Online Format
- online text
- image
LCCN Permalink
Additional Metadata Formats
IIIF Presentation Manifest
Part of
Format
Contributor
Dates
Language
Subject
Featured in
- Elliot's Debates | Continental Congress and the Constitutional Convention | Articles and Essays | A Century of Lawmaking for a New Nation: U.S. Congressional Documents and Debates 1774 to 1875 | Digital Collections
- Today in History - October 27
- Today in History - January 9
- Today in History - January 13
- Today in History - December 5
- Today in History - January 23
- Today in History - September 17
- Today in History - December 18
- Today in History - December 23
- Today in History - November 15