Periodical Image 1 of The Remonstrance, Quarterly publication of Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women
BOSTON, JANUARY, 1909.
The Remonstrance is published quarterly by the Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women. It expresses the views of women in Massachusetts, Maine, Rhode Island, New York, Illinois, Iowa, Oregon, Washington, and other states who believe that the great majority of their sex do not want the ballot, and that to force it upon them would not only be an injustice to women, but would lessen their influence for good and imperil the community.
The Remonstrants ask a thoughtful consideration of their views in the interest
of fair discussion.
Any one who desires to receive the
quarterly numbers can do so by enclosing
25 cents in stamps to the Treasurer,
MRS. JAMES M. CODMAN,
Walnut St., Brookline.
Information in regard to The Remonstrance and other publications of the Association may be obtained from the Corresponding Secretary, Mrs. Charles P.
Strong, 24 Concord Avenue, Cambridge.
State Otgauniatlons Opposed to 'the
Further Extension of Suffrage to
35 Branch Committees; 14,163 members in
245 cities, towns, and villages of
MRS. G. HOWLAND SHAW, President.
MRS. J. RANDOLPH COOLIDGE,
MISS ANNA L. DAWES,
MRS. CHARLES ELIOT GUILD,
MRS. CHARLES D. HOMANS,
MISS AGNES IRWIN, Dean of P
MRS. HENRY M. WHITNEY,
MRS. JAMES M. CODMAN, Treasurer,
Walnut Street, Brookline.
MISS ELIZABETH JOHNSON, Rec. Sec'y.
MRS. CHARLES P. STRONG, Cor. Sec'y,
24 Concord Avenue, Cambridge.
MRS. FRANCIS M. SCOTT, President.
MRS. ARTHUR M. DODGE, First Vice-President.
MRS. ELIHU ROOT,
MRS. RICHARD WATSON GILDER, -,
MRS. WILLIAM A. PUTNAM,
MRS. ROBERT McVICKAR, MRS. GEORGE DOUGLAS MILLER, MRS. WILLIAM P. NORTHRUP,
MRS. FRANCIS S. BANGS, Treasurer.
MRS. GEORGE PHILLIPS, Secretary,
29 West 39th Street, Room 819,
New York City.
Chairmen of Auxiliaries.
MRS. WILLIAM A. PUTNAM, Chairman,
70 Willow Street,. Brooklyn.
MISS JAL CE HILL CHITTENDEN, Secretary.
MRS. LINDLEY MURRAY, Jr., Treasurer. MRS. ROBERT MeVICKAR,
269 North Fulton Avenue, Mt. Vernon. MRS. GEORGE DOUGLAS MILLER. MRS. WINSLOW CRANNELL,
138 State Street, Albany.
MRS. WILLIAM P. NORTHRUP,
80 Jewett Avenue, Buffalo.
MRS. MELVIN P. FRANK, President,
MRS. SIDNEY W. THAXTER, Secretary,
MRS. CHARLES S. OGDEN, Portland. MRS. JAMES P. BAXTER, Portland. MRS. CLARENCE H. CORNING, Portland. MRS. F. A. QUINBY, Portland. MISS LOUISA SPRING, Portland. MISS CATHERINE P. TALBOT, Portland. MISS HANNAH L. TALBOT, Portland. MISS MARY KING LONGFELLOW, Portland. MISS ELINOR S. MOODY, Portland. MISS MARION RICHMOND WEEKS,
MRS. JOHN F. THOMPSON, Portland. MRS. JOHN M. GLIDDEN, Newcastle. MRS. P. M. BLAKE, Bangor. MRS. F. 0. ROBINSON, Brunswick.
MRS. CAROLINE F. CORBIN, President.
MRS.i S. M. NICKERSON, ie-Presidnts. MRS. R. J. OGLESBY, VePresdents. MISS J. C. FAIRFIELD, Secretary,
597 Dearborn Avenue, Chicago. MRS. A. T. GALT, Auditor.
MRS. R. W. WILBUR, President,
780 Lovejoy Street, Portland.
MRS. WM. S. LADD, Vice-Pre t.
MRS. J. B. MONTGOMERY, ie-Pridents. MRS. WALLACE MeCAMANT, Treasurer. MISS ELEANOR E. GILE, Secretary.
IO0 WA COMLMIrTTEE.
MRS. J. H. MERRILL, 509 W. Fourth Street,
1RHODBE ISLAND COMMITTEE.
MRS. CHARLES W. LIPPITT, Providence.
MRS. JOHN LEARY, President. MRS. G. W. BACON, Secretary,
51i 10th Avenue, South.
MRS. CHAUNCEY W. GRIGGS, President. MRS. FITCH B. STACEY, Vice-President. MRS. A. B. BULL, Secretary,
32 N. E. Street.
IN PROCESS OF DEFEAT.
AMERICAN suffragists have objected strenuously to the phrase in one. of Mrs. Humphry Ward's letters in the London Times, in which she described the suffrage movement in the United States as ".in process of defeat."
Yet it requires only a glance at the record to prove that Mrs. Ward's phrase is accurately descriptive. When a propaganda, persistently and energetically pushed in more than half the states in the Union, has not achieved a single success worth mentioning in twelve years, may it not truthfully be said to be " in process of defeat "? This is the record of the suffrage movement in the United States, The list of suffrage successes which the suffrage newspapers are so fond of publishing closes with 1896, when the women of Utah and Idaho were given the ballot. Since that date no state has granted full suffrage to women; no state has given them municipal suffrage; the only gains have been unimportant enactments in a few states, such as those which allow taxpaying women to Vote on . the rare occasions when questions of expenditure or borrowing are submitted to the vote of taxpayers.
The record in Massachusetts is instructive in this connection. In 1897 the Massachusetts House of Representatives defeated a resolve for the submission of a suffrage amendment to the constitution by a vote of 53 yeas to 86 nays. Ten years later, only 14 members of the House voted for a similar resolve, and the negative vote was I25. The intervening years had shown a steady decline in the favoring vote; in I898, to 44 votes; in 1899, to 3 votes, and so on.
As to municipal suffrage, in 1894 the House actually passed a municipal suffrage bill by a vote of 122 to io6, and only the conservatism of the Senate prevented its enactment. Last year the House defeated a similar bill by a vote of 30 yeas to 99 nays. Does not this look as if the suffrage movement were " in process of defeat "?
The suffragists resent the intimation that the formation of associations of American women to oppose woman suffrage has had anything to do w-th
About this Item
- The Remonstrance, Quarterly publication of Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women
- Contributor Names
- Remonstance, The (Publisher)
- Created / Published
- Boston, Massachusetts, Jan-09
- Subject Headings
- - Roosevelt, Theodore
- - Root, Elihu
- - Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women
- - anti-suffrage arguments
- - Abbott, Lyman
- - Periodicals
- - "An Anti-Suffrage Meeting in New York," Remonstrance, page 3, reprints Theodore Roosevelt's November 10, 1908, letter as a preface to Lyman Abbott's December 4, 1908, addresses; and Elihu Root's November 23, 1908, letter urging women to study the art of government. This Roosevelt letter is referenced in his February 25, 1909, letter to Anne Fitzhugh Miller (scrapbook 7:91); this Root letter is referenced in Anne Miller's March letter to the Geneva Daily Times (scrapbook 7:101)
- - Remonstrance contends that suffrage movement is in decline and lists defeats of 1906-1908
- serial publication, 6 p.
- Call Number/Physical Location
- JK1881 .N357 sec. XVI, no. 3-9 NAWSA Coll
- series: Miller NAWSA Suffrage Scrapbooks, 1897-1911; Scrapbook 7 (1908-1909)
- Source Collection
- Miller NAWSA Suffrage Scrapbooks, 1897-1911
- Rare Book And Special Collections Division
- Digital Id
- Online Format
- online text
- Miller Nawsa Suffrage Scrapbooks, 1897 to 1911: Miller Nawsa Suffrage Scrapbooks, 1897 to 1911; Scrapbook 7 (1908 to 1909) (313)
- Miller Nawsa Suffrage Scrapbooks, 1897 to 1911 (1,808)
- National American Woman Suffrage Association Collection (1,935)
- Rare Book and Special Collections Division (23,354)
- American Memory (501,943)
The Library of Congress is not aware of any copyright restrictions in the National Women Suffrage Association Collection. Researchers should watch for modern documents (for example, foreign works and works published in the United States less than 95 years ago, or unpublished if the author died less than 70 years ago) that may be copyrighted.
Responsibility for determining the legal status of an item and securing any necessary permissions ultimately rests with persons desiring to use the item.
More about Copyright and other Restrictions
For guidance about compiling full citations consult Citing Primary Sources.
Credit Line: Library of Congress, Rare Book and Special Collections Division, National American Woman Suffrage Association Collection.
Citations are generated automatically from bibliographic data as a convenience, and may not be complete or accurate.
Chicago citation style:
Remonstance, The. The Remonstrance, Quarterly publication of Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women. Boston, Massachusetts, Jan-09, 1909. Periodical. https://www.loc.gov/item/rbcmiller001235/.
APA citation style:
Remonstance, T. (1909) The Remonstrance, Quarterly publication of Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women. Boston, Massachusetts, Jan-09. [Periodical] Retrieved from the Library of Congress, https://www.loc.gov/item/rbcmiller001235/.
MLA citation style:
Remonstance, The. The Remonstrance, Quarterly publication of Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women. Boston, Massachusetts, Jan-09, 1909. Periodical. Retrieved from the Library of Congress, <www.loc.gov/item/rbcmiller001235/>.